Why Pricing Strategy Can Make or Break a Seller’s Outcome

One of the most misunderstood aspects of selling a home isn’t where a property ultimately sells — it’s how you get there.

I recently closed a transaction for a seller whose home was a custom build in an established subdivision. There were no strong recent comparable sales, which immediately raised two critical considerations:

• Buyer brokers would be relying heavily on limited data
• Appraisers have strict rules about what can and cannot be used as comparables

With that in mind, we made a very intentional pricing decision:
We priced the home slightly above what the comps strictly supported — but conservatively and strategically.

Here’s why pricing strategy matters 👇

📈 Within two days on the market, we received two competing offers, which quickly escalated into a bidding situation.

That competition allowed me to negotiate:

$74,000 over asking price
An appraisal gap contingency, reducing risk if the home didn’t appraise
Inspection contingency fully waived
HOA document contingency waived
One month of post-closing occupancy at no cost, giving my out-of-state seller time to coordinate an estate sale

Just as important: having multiple offers in hand helped support value for the appraiser — and the property did appraise at value.

Here’s the key takeaway:

Had we priced the home closer to the final sale price from the start, the outcome likely would have been very different:

• Fewer (or no) competing offers
• Less leverage to negotiate strong terms
• Greater appraisal risk

📌 Pricing isn’t about chasing the highest number.
It’s about creating momentum, leverage, and buyer confidence.

When done correctly, pricing strategy doesn’t just improve the sale price — it improves terms, certainty, and outcomes.

This is the difference between simply listing a home…
…and strategically positioning it for the best possible result.


Adrienne DeGuere | Sotheby’s International Realty – Santa Fe
I help sellers navigate complex pricing scenarios with data, strategy, and a deep understanding of how buyers, agents, and appraisers actually behave — especially in nuanced or low-comp markets.

If you’re considering selling and want a strategy-first approach, I’m always happy to talk.